This is a few days late, but Favre’s retirement pushed this back…
Somewhere, in a galaxy far, far away sits a Steeler fan who possesses the one thing that I really admire in the rare sports fan – objectivity. He’s sitting in his Lay-Z-Boy recliner watching his QB throw 3 interceptions in a playoff game against the Jacksonville Jaguars. As the game unfolds and his beloved Steelers lose, he gets up, says “Ben, you blew it”, and goes to bed.He doesn’t blame the Steelers porous offensive line, or the receivers for dropped passes. He doesn’t blame the defense for allowing the offensively-potent Jaguars to drive deep into the red zone in overtime and win. Nope. He simply looks at his quarterback, and shakes his head.
He’s been hit over the head with hand of reality, and chuckles at his inability to notice the obvious – that his franchise quarterback is simply not good enough. Three interceptions – all awful decisions gave the game away. Most Steelers fans are still complaining about the phantom holding call on the Steelers, and the “missed offensive holding” on Garrard’s game-sealing 4th down conversion, instead of thinking about how Ben killed three drives with his erratic decision making and errant accuracy.
In reality, Ben’s never been good enough. The Steelers won Super Bowl XL in the most unconvincing fashion…and with very little help from their second-year QB. Aside from the oft-debated rushing TD, Roethlisberger did everything that he could to lose the game. He’s the only QB to ever walk away from the Super Bowl with a ring and a passer rating of 22.6.
Fortunately for Ben, he was drafted into a ridiculously strong football organization with a stacked team. Let’s face it…that Steelers team could’ve won the Super Bowl with any average QB behind center, a concept very similar to the 2000 Ravens who won Super Bowl XXXV with Trent Dilfer.
Who gets the credit now, though? Ben Roethlisberger, that’s who. As Ben sniffs his $36 million in guaranteed money for signing his new 8-year, $102 million contract, he has to be thinking about how he’s benefited from the complementary blinders handed out to the Steelers faithful nationwide. Here’s a guy who lucked into a great situation. He came into a great team and just needed to not screw up. He did just that and won a Super Bowl, as well as most of his starts. Congratulations for that. Here’s a cookie. I’ll let you know when you’re worth $102 million, though.
When you’re capable of consistently winning games where you pass more than 30 times, that’ll help. When you learn how to find your open receivers quickly so you’re not making your offensive line work double-time to save your ass, we’ll talk. When you stop making awful decisions while in the pocket resulting in interceptions, you can at least suggest a number. When you limit the spectacular looking plays because you actually learn how to read a blitz and get the ball out of your hand, resulting in a quarterback style similar to those good QBs – you know…those guys named Manning, Marino, Montana, Unitas, Young, Favre, and Brady – I’ll talk to your agent about an elite contract extension. Until you learn how to throw to your “short” receivers over the middle without putting them in harms way with high throws, you can enjoy your rookie contract. Until you can do at least a few of those thing, keep your mouth shut about a big-money contract and your need for tall receivers.
Big Ben and the Steeler faithful have truly lost their minds regarding his new contract extension. It’s not like Ben has ever needed to take a franchise from the bottom and carry it back up to the top, like Peyton Manning, or even Drew Brees. It’s not like Ben has had Tom Brady-esque success in his first 4 years (insert jealous Steelers fan squeals of “cheating”).
Ben’s a good quarterback in a great system. He’s the king of the backfield screen pass that goes for 40 yards. He’s the master of elusiveness. Of course, he’s also the master of making more drama than necessary to make a simple pass. Oh, and he’s also the executioner of his receivers over the middle, too arrogant to wear a helmet when riding a motorcycle, and incapable of winning team MVP honors in a season where, in the words of the Steeler Nation, “he’s the only reason that the Steelers had a good year”. That award went to “Silverback”, James Harrison.
The same quarterback who was gifted a Super Bowl-caliber team and experienced gift wrapped success, has now received his second gift from the Steelers – one of the highest contracts ever for a quarterback.
Congrats, Ben. Now put your running shoes on, because that contract cost you your best offensive lineman. Be sure to wear your helmet!