My only experience with the Guitar Hero franchise was at a Best Buy about 6 months ago. I tried to play Danzig’s “Mother” for about a minute and promptly decided that it wasn’t worth the effort.
I guess my time and effort has taken a price cut because on Sunday Davis and I spent around 7 hours playing Guitar Hero III. I have to admit that it was a lot more fun that I had expected. We managed to beat the game on medium, which isn’t a really a great accomplishment. At least not in a society overrun with lazy children with amazing hand-eye coordination who never leaving the house thanks to games like this. I digress. It felt like a decent accomplishment for us, especially after the annoyingly difficult final battle between me and Lucifer (Lou) on “The Devil Went Down to Georgia”.
I should also add that the songs that were chosen for the most part are really good, and it’s funny how this game forced me to appreciate the guitar parts of songs that I never really paid much attention to. I guess that happens when you’re forced to listen to the same song 20 times or more. Ha ha.
Anyway, I always thought that I would hate the game because I can play guitar at a relatively high level, and despite the shape of the controller – in this case a Les Paul – it’s pretty far from really playing guitar. In some ways I’m completely on-point. Naturally, I hate the fact that you don’t really strum the way that you would on a guitar. The game forces you to ignore a lot of strokes which is really difficult on songs that I actually know well, since I would be strumming the notes when they were actually being sounded and not when the little indicators were telling me to. It’s just unnatural at this point for songs that I know.
The other thing that I’m not totally sold on is the controller. Guitar is really easy for me because I can slide my hand up and down on the strings quickly and I don’t find myself lost too often, but the GH controller has 5 buttons and I really have trouble maneuvering between the two positions that I’ve sort of defined for myself (index finger on green to pinkie on blue, and index finger on red to pinkie on orange). I often find myself in between two buttons and unable to recover once I lose my place on the tiny “fretboard”.
Anyway, all complaints of my inability to adapt to the silly controller are basically moot since endless amounts of people, guitar players and non-guitar players, have mastered this game. We’ve started going through the hard level, so hopefully things get better quickly. Sadly, I’ll probably master this game while my guitars gather dust in the next room. I can’t wait until Rock Band comes out and Davis and I decide that we can sell all of our real music equipment because our virtual band just takes up less room and we don’t have to leave the house for gigs!