I don’t want to spoil anything (but I probably will), so all I can say is Cloverfield absolutely blew my mind. It’s definitely one of the best movies I’ve seen in recent memory, but it’s a movie that a lot of people aren’t going to like.
Yeah, there are a few things that are a bit unbelievable, but nothing is distracting enough to ruin the enjoyment of the movie (camera batteries really last that long?). Spielberg must be pissed that he didn’t do War of the Worlds in the same fashion, because they’re quite similar in a sense, but where this movie succeeds and his failed was that War of the Worlds went off into directions that were too far from its successes. War of the Worlds started off pounding this realistic, well-executed fear into the viewer, but then it became a typical approach to the modern movie.
Cloverfield didn’t stray too far from its successes. It was simply and hour-and-a-half of fear and entertainment. A lot of people complain about the camera work, but it’s perfect (okay, maybe it’s a little ridiculous to think that a guy would continue to worry about filming the ENTIRE catastrophic event, but for whatever reason, it didn’t bother me here). There was a warning at the ticket counter about motion sickness, but I didn’t feel it at all. For me, having the movie shot from the first person was really cool, and highly effective. Maybe I’m just tired of this dolly-perfect camera work every time I go to a movie. Ooh…look at that incredible pan! Ha ha. Screw that. Give this desensitized American something he doesn’t see every day.
Is there an element of Blair Witch at work here with the camera work? I guess, but this is far better than Blair Witch. The characters did a fine job in terms of acting, and in the end, I felt that they were as convincing as they could be for a movie that was this over-the-top.
What the heck is that thing? By now, you know it’s a monster. More times than not, I don’t buy into monster flicks, but again, this time I wasn’t bothered by it. Just like in “The Mist”, the monster(s) aren’t really the focal point of the movie. The focus in the movie is on the way people react to crisis situations. What happens when fear takes over our weak minds?
Here’s my favorite part (SPOILER ALERT!!!), and to get my point across, I sort of have to add a spoiler. Most movies in this genre provide some root of this evil destroying New York, or whatever city happens to be the focal point. Maybe it’s an Alien invasion (War of the Worlds). Maybe it’s a virus (28 Days Later). This movie doesn’t do that…ever. That only aids in the success of maintaining fear. You never find out why this monster is destroying New York. You don’t know what it is, you don’t know where it came from, and we’ll never find that out – at least from solely watching the movie.
You’re just spending an hour-and-a-half in the lives of a few regular people, like you or I, put in the middle of a horrifying experience. The setup lays it out to be that way, and the execution of the entire film maintains that integrity. The characters are fragile, physically and mentally, just like you or I. The characters don’t do anything extraordinary. This isn’t some Americans-always-save-the-day story like Independence Day. This is a well-done, and highly entertaining thrillfest, with solid special effects, and a simple story of hope and survival. Go check it out to see if they do, in fact, survive. My only recommendation…see it in the theater.
When it’s all said and done, I think Bad Robot – the production company behind that awesome show we call “Lost” – did an excellent job.