Yesterday, our friends over at PETA hit out at the Baltimore Ravens for the organization’s plans to have a real raven fly out of the tunnel before the players are introduced at each home game starting this season. Here’s the letter sent to the Ravens VP of Marketing yesterday:
Dear Ms. Dow:
I am writing on behalf of PETA and our more than 2 million members and supporters. Dedicated to the protection of animals, PETA was founded in Maryland and has tens of thousands of members and supporters in the state, including many in Baltimore. We have received numerous complaints from people who are gravely concerned and upset that the Baltimore Ravens are planning to feature live African white nape ravens (members of the Corvidae family) at upcoming games, including having the birds “fly out of a smoky tunnel.” After carefully considering the following information, we urge you to cancel plans to feature live birds at games immediately and implement a policy prohibiting the use of live animals at all Ravens games.
Anyone who has attended a sporting event can attest to the sheer intensity of these games. The energy is palpable, and it is part of what makes attending these events so enjoyable. But the bright lights, screaming fans, and loud noises–such as air horns, bands, and amplified sound systems–are terrifying for animals who can’t possibly understand what is going on. Regardless of how these birds are trained, they are likely to be severely distressed by the overwhelming confusion of the situation. Corvids are highly intelligent animals–one study found that that they have cognitive abilities on par with those of great apes. They form strong (and sometimes lifelong) partner bonds and possess a strong sense of community.
Public sentiment is rapidly moving away from the antiquated notion that animal displays are acceptable or fair to animals. Costumed humans are undeniably the most effective–and humane–entertainment for sports fans. The versatility of human performers allows them to entertain and interact directly with fans throughout the game.
Can I please hear from you regarding this important matter right away?
Sincerely,
Kristie Phelps
Assistant Director
Animals in Entertainment Campaign
Did anyone else laugh…at least a little? Am I out of line for thinking PETA should really find something better to do with their time? Seriously. PETA’s Director, Debby Leahy comes off sounding so petty and childish with her snide remarks like, “If the Ravens want to increase fan support, they don’t need cheap gimmicks. They just need to start winning games.” The last time I checked, I don’t think the Ravens were struggling for fan support. We’re not talking about Atlanta here. Plus, PETA isn’t above using “cheap gimmicks” themselves. Remember the nude women in cages? Of course you do…that gimmick worked…aside from the fact that I still don’t mind ordering a filet. Now, if I think with a PETA-sized mentality, I could go, “using nude women in cages exploits and demeans women.” PETA would say, “well, we’re humans, and we chose to put ourselves in a cage for the sake of animal cruelty”. I would say, “exactly…who are you to talk about cheap gimmicks, when you chose to sell animal rights initiatives by taking your clothes off in public. There are kids walking around who could see you.” If we’re all going to be sensitive about every little thing, let’s be fair. Let’s also consider that there’s just over 2 million members in PETA…approximately .8% of our population. It always amazes me how PETA even gets airtime for stupid issues like these, and how with such a small percentage of population, they think their issues are on-par with the rest of the country’s concerns. A little arrogant there, huh, PETA?
These people are so over-the-top it’s kind of sad. I especially love this other quote from Ms. Leahy, “Edgar Allan Poe would be spinning in his grave if he knew that his poem had prompted Baltimore to harm ravens in the name of marketing”. Really, Debby? You know the mentality of a guy who died 159 years ago? I would think that a guy who married his 13-year-old cousin who was half his age at the time isn’t necessarily worried about birds. In fact, being that he only made a whopping $9 off of “The Raven”, he’d probably be thrilled to see some financial success and legacy brought about from his poem. Way to attempt to speak for Mr. Poe, Debby. Bringing up Poe’s name to help dramatize the situation to your idiot followers is, in itself, a cheap gimmick…ma’am.
The reality is that these ravens were brought in as baby birds, and are being cared for way better than any wild bird. Just as we’ve adapted to PETA’s nonsense at times, these birds will adapt to their surroundings. Similar to caged animals in zoos, or dolphins performing in front of large crowds, these Ravens will be trained to deal with the stadium noise and surroundings. They’re going to live a pretty good life and are going to be able to avoid the struggles of nature – fighting for food, finding shelter, and sickness. It’s not like the Ravens are asking the birds to do something they’re not naturally capable of, like horse racing does. Just fly out of a tunnel, crap on the opposing team’s fans and players, and fly back to your trainer…10-12 times a years, max. Plus, with a billionaire owner, I’m sure these birds are going to have a more cushy life than most PETA members.
Is the Ravens organization using a shameless gimmick to market the team and game? Sure. Is having live birds flying out of the tunnel on game days necessary? Nope, but does it really matter? This isn’t an oil spill. This isn’t over-fishing. This isn’t dog fighting. This isn’t factory farming. No one is eating the animals, or mistreating them. I could even understand raising concerns about taking these particular ravens – native to Africa – out of their ecosystem, and the possibility of diseases being introduced to local bird species if they got away, but the things that Kristie Phelps brought up is total speculation. The Ravens have a professional caretaker dealing with these birds. If that guy is fine with it, I’m going to side with his professional opinion, not some PETA hacks with nothing better to do with their lives than worry about two, yes, TWO birds in the entire world.
The only thing that bugged me a little bit about the whole thing is that the organization is going to dye the white nape on the birds black to resemble ravens native to the U.S. If you’re going to argue against something, pick that, but let us enjoy seeing this spectacle, PETA-free, no matter how cheesy it is. I just think PETA trying to force any form of policy on these lines is absurd. Stick to real animal cruelty issues like cleaning up corporate factory farming, and stay out of the NFL.
Of course, if these people can speak for dead people, they’re probably equally adept at knowing exactly what animals think and feel.